The Amalgam Rankings!

Starting with episode 50, Luke and Devin started to cover Marvel Vs DC which led into Amalgam – which was covered in 51 and 52. We ended up doing a definitive list of the best to worst Amalgam titles! Don’t argue with us because you are wrong!

The Amalgamated List of Devin and Luke’s Rankings

  1. Iron Lantern
  2. Dark Claw Adventures
  3. Spider-boy
  4. Spider-Boy Team Up
  5. X-Patrol
  6. The Exciting X-Patrol
  7. Bullets and Bracelets
  8. Challengers of the Fantastic
  9. Super Soldier Man of War
  10. BatThing
  11. Doctor Strangefate
  12. Generation Hex
  13. Bruce Wayne Agent of SHIELD
  14. Super Soldier
  15. Legends of the Dark Claw
  16. Assassins
  17. Thorion of the New Asgods
  18. The Magnetic Men Featuring Magneto
  19. Magneto and the Magnetic Men
  20. Amazon
  21. Lobo the Duck
  22. Speed Demon
  23. JLX
  24. JLX Unleashed

Luke’s Amalgam Ranking

  1. Dark Claw Adventures
  2. Iron Lantern
  3. Spider-Boy Team Up
  4. Spider-boy
  5. X-Patrol
  6. The Exciting X-Patrol
  7. Doctor Strangefate
  8. Bullets and Bracelets
  9. Challengers of the Fantastic
  10. Generation Hex
  11. BatThing
  12. Super Soldier: Man of War
  13. Super Soldier
  14. Legends of the Dark Claw
  15. Bruce Wayne Agent of SHIELD
  16. Assassins
  17. Thorion of the New Asgods
  18. The Magnetic Men Featuring Magneto
  19. Amazon
  20. Lobo the Duck
  21. Magneto and the Magnetic Men
  22. Speed Demon
  23. JLX
  24. JLX Unleashed

Devin’s Amalgam Rankings

  1. Iron Lantern
  2. Spider-boy
  3. Dark Claw Adventures
  4. Spider-Boy Team Up
  5. X-Patrol
  6. Bullets and Bracelets
  7. The Exciting X-Patrol
  8. Challengers of the Fantastic
  9. Bruce Wayne Agent of SHIELD
  10. Super Soldier: Man of War
  11. Super Soldier
  12. BatThing
  13. Generation Hex
  14. Legends of the Dark Claw
  15. Assassins
  16. Doctor Strangefate
  17. Thorion of the New Asgods
  18. Magneto and the Magnetic Men
  19. The Magnetic Men Featuring Magneto
  20. Lobo the Duck
  21. Amazon
  22. Speed Demon
  23. JLX
  24. JLX Unleashed

And then for the letter column titles that are not just the book title – the winner in that case would be Bat-Thing.

The Amalgamated Letter Column Title Rankings

  1. Sock It To Oa – Iron Lantern
  2. Shred ‘em And Weep – Legends of the Dark Claw
  3. The Magneto Meter – The Magentic Men Featuring Magneto
  4. Last Writes – Assassins
  5. Challengers Mountain O’ Mail – Challengers of the Fantastic
  6. JLX-Press – JLX
  7. Letters to Paradise – Amazon
  8. Patrol Log – X-Patrol
  9. The Source Strikes – Thorion of the New Gods
  10. Magnetic Mail Call – Magneto and the Magnetic Men
  11. P.O. Box: Cadmus – Spider-boy
  12. The Strangefate Letters – Doctor StrangeFate
  13. Mail Call – Super Soldier

Luke’s Letter Column Title Rankings

  1. Sock It To Oa – Iron Lantern
  2. Last Writes – Assassins
  3. The Magneto Meter – The Magentic Men Featuring Magneto
  4. Challengers Mountain O’ Mail – Challengers of the Fantastic
  5. Shred ‘em And Weep – Legends of the Dark Claw
  6. Magnetic Mail Call – Magneto and the Magnetic Men
  7. JLX-Press – JLX
  8. The Strangefate Letters – Doctor StrangeFate
  9. P.O. Box: Cadmus – Spider-boy
  10. Patrol Log – X-Patrol
  11. The Source Strikes – Thorion of the New Gods
  12. Mail Call – Super Soldier
  13. Letters to Paradise – Amazon

Devin’s Letter Column Title Rankings

  1. Shred ‘em And Weep – Legends of the Dark Claw
  2. Letters to Paradise – Amazon
  3. Sock It To Oa – Iron Lantern
  4. The Source Strikes – Thorion of the New Gods
  5. Patrol Log – X-Patrol
  6. The Magneto Meter – The Magentic Men Featuring Magneto
  7. JLX-Press – JLX
  8. Challengers Mountain O’ Mail – Challengers of the Fantastic
  9. Last Writes – Assassins
  10. Magnetic Mail Call – Magneto and the Magnetic Men
  11. P.O. Box: Cadmus – Spider-boy
  12. The Strangefate Letters – Doctor StrangeFate
  13. Mail Call – Super Soldier